Sunday, August 5, 2012

Thoughts on the 2012 Hall of Fame Enshrinement Ceremony.


Well, it’s been a while hasn’t it. There’s a lot of stuff to talk about, but we’ll get to those items when the time is right. There’s an enshrinement ceremony to talk about and some legends that deserve this blog’s recognition.

Willie Roaf


        The Player: What can I say about Willie Roaf? He was one of the most dominating offensive tackles in the NFL for thirteen years. He would be recognized as such more widely if he didn’t spend most of that time on the perpetual doormat that was the 90s New Orleans Saints. His true greatness as a dominating one-on-one blocker, in both the running and passing game, was on full display and more widely recognized when he went to Kansas City for the final four years of his career, and paved the way for one of the best offenses in the early 2000s. He went to 11 Pro Bowls and was named an All-Pro 7 times. All-Decade in both the 90s and 2000s, Roaf is one of the most underrated of the great offensive tackles in this game’s history.

        The Speech: Willie is so big he has to lean down to the mic. He’s clearly nervous and not used to speaking in front of a lot of people, stuttering quite a bit. He is somewhat going backwards, thanking his family before going through teammates and coaches. Very interesting fact dropped that he played at the same high school as legendary receiver Don Hutson. Other than that, the speech was very by the numbers.

Jack Butler

        The Player: The guy who younger fans have forgotten, Jack Butler in the personification of a player who’s excellence was overshadowed by his team’s mediocrity. The Steelers of the 50s were known for two things, a tough defense and a hopelessly bad record. I’m very certain, that their inability to have sustained success in the regular season or any form of success in the post season is what kept Butler out of the Hall of Fame until recently. Butler intercepted 52 passes in 103 games. That’s a pick every two games. That’s enough to lead the NFL during his career between 1951 and 1959. He retired the second leading interceptor in NFL history. Named to four Pro Bowls and three All-NFL teams as well as the All-Decade team of the 50s, Butler has finally taken his place among the greatest defensive backs in the history of the game.

        The Speech: Jack is incredibly lucid for a man of his age and very well spoken. His speech was short and sweet, addressing who he wanted to thank without going through all the names or sharing stories. He couldn’t work the crowd, asking cheering Steelers fans to stop so he could do his speech, though he did work in a bit of humor at the end. Truly, an old school style speech.

Chris Doleman

        The Player: While originally being drafted as a linebacker, Chris Doleman became the model of the modern undersized defensive end. Doleman played with a lot of energy and was able to beat tackles to the edges with best of his generation. He finished his career with 150.5 sacks, good for fourth all-time at the time of his retirement. He never won a Super Bowl which often is a something that hurts Hall of Fame cases, though he made the Pro Bowl with all three teams he played for, eight total Pro Bowl appearance, made First Team All-Pro three times and was named to the All-Decade team of the 90s. He was also known as one of the best as forcing fumbles during his time, knocking the ball loose 44 times over his fifteen year career.  His talent was often unrecognized, but when it mattered most, he was finally acknowledged as one of the game’s best.

        The Speech: Chris is perhaps the first person I can think of, who thanked a fantasy football league and his sponsors, though not the first to thank god. Thanking god tends to be a running theme in these speeches. This is probably the most cookie cutter of speeches, going through the whole thing as his life story. But that’s also what makes it great to listen to. I’ve also never heard someone go on so long about his attorney. But still, I liked this speech.

Cortez Kennedy

        The Player: Playing in the middle of the defensive line, it’s often hard to get recognition. It’s even harder when you’re team stinks. But Cortez Kennedy’s dominance on the football field was so great, that no one could deny it. In 1992, while playing for a 2-14 Seattle Seahawks team, Kennedy won the NFL’s defensive player of the year award while recording 14 sacks, an extremely high amount for a defensive tackle. He played his entire career in Seattle, which until recently was like playing your entire career in Alaska, no one outside your market recognizes you. Well, like Steve Largent before him, Kennedy made fans sit up and notice as he was almost unblockable, in spite of being double and triple teamed most games. He was named to eight Pro Bowls and was a five time First-Team All-Pro. Another member from the All-Decade team of the 90s, Kennedy was simply dominant and would have been in on the first or second ballot if he played in a bigger market or won a Super Bowl.

        The Speech: Cortez, while stuttering a bit, is doing a good job mixing in in stories and humor. Cortez worked in a lot of those stories and his humor. While he has some trouble speaking clearly, he really has a lot of the charisma and charm that people associate with the Deep South. He’s going long, but he acknowledges it with a nice joke to the people off stage. Good speech, lots of stories and humor that worked out, even if it was a bit meandering at times.

Dermontti Dawson

        The Player: It’s rare that any team can replace one of the all-time best players at their position with a player of equal or greater caliber. Pittsburgh had the good fortune to do that with their center position. The year before Hall of Famer Mike Webster left the Steelers, Dermontti Dawson was drafted. His sophomore season, he stepped in for Webster and never looked back. He became one of the best Centers in the history of the game and revolutionized the position as perhaps the first center that pulled on running plays. Before Dawson, Centers were considered too big and bulky to keep up with outside lead blocks. But he wasn’t that. Not by any stretch of the imagination. He lead the offensive line of one of the best running teams in the 90s and was regularly recognized as such, earning seven Pro Bowl invitations and six All-Pro recognitions. Not a bad way to follow up on a legend huh?

        The Speech: Another speech starting with thanking Jesus. Got to admit, it feels like the first time anyone has ever actually thanked their parents for giving them life. Dermontti’s son is very enthusiastic and fired up. Dermontti is the first one to try to use this stage to send a message, which he’s working into his story.  I really like how he’s giving props to his predecessor and fellow Hall of Fame center Mike Webster; it shows a lot of class. This was definitely a solid speech.

Curtis Martin

        The Player: I’m not sure what exactly I need to say here. Curtis Martin finished his career as the fourth all-time leading rusher, was only the second running back in history (the first being Barry Sanders) to rush for one-thousand yards in the first ten years of his career and was the oldest player to ever lead the league in rushing when he ran for 1697 yards in 2004 at the age of 31. With all of that on the table, is it any wonder he’s here? Oh, and he was the offensive Rookie of the Year in 1995 and attended five Pro Bowls. He was never flashy, only effective, which combined with the lack of a Super Bowl win, probably is the reason he’s often over-looked as being one of the best running backs in the history of the NFL. There’s no doubt, he earned this honor.

        The Speech: Early on, this looks like a great speech. He freely admits to his doubts about playing football and how he connected to the game in unusual ways. Great story about all of the events of the weekend and dear god the stories about his family life. While his speech isn’t structured in any traditional way, his stories and the emotion with which these stories are being delivered, I can’t help but be carried along. This is most definitely among my favorite all time induction speeches. 

No comments:

Post a Comment