Monday, March 28, 2011

Top 20 Pass Rushers

Alright, now the staff at ESPN has decided to switch from pure positions to general roles, focusing this week on pass rushers. Here’s the link to the article: http://espn.go.com/blog/nfcnorth/tag/_/name/2011-pass-rushers-power-rankings


                ESPN’s list consists of:

Thursday, March 17, 2011

Top 30 Runningbacks

Alright, last week ESPN did their best wide receivers now its running backs. So we’ll start off the same way we did for the wide receivers. Here’s the link to the article: http://espn.go.com/blog/afcsouth/post/_/id/22193/power-rankings-top-10-nfl-running-backs?prosaction=newpost&status=ok

                ESPN’s list consists of:

Sunday, March 13, 2011

Wide Receiver Power Rankings and Top 30

Not too long ago, ESPN began a new feature on their website, wherein eight writers associated with ESPN rank the top 10 players at a given position. They started this past Tuesday with the wide receivers. Here’s the link to the original article: http://espn.go.com/blog/nfcwest/post/_/id/33997/power-rankings-top-10-nfl-receivers

                Whatever you may think of ESPN and their coverage, it’s inarguable that they can at least think up some good talking points. While I was probably going to do a similar set of lists closer to the season, it makes more sense for me to critique these lists and provide my own take, rather than coming up with them again in a few months.

Thursday, March 10, 2011

Since When have Turnovers NOT Mattered?


                Last I checked, the old adage that “You win the turnover battle, you win the game” still held true. Think about the last two Super Bowl Champions, they weren’t the teams that necessarily stopped their opponents the most consistently (though Green Bay’s 2010 defense is FAR superior to the Saints 2009 defense), but they both excelled in getting turnovers and capitalizing on said turnovers. No matter how you look at the game, turnovers are still vital to having a quality defense. A defense that is key to winning a championship.

                Yet, in-spite of this iron-clad fact, there has been a trend in the mainstream media and fandom of discounting the importance of interceptions, particularly for cornerbacks. Instead, the focus has shifted to looking at how often a corner will allow pass to be completed, to the point of excluding all other aspects of the game. Perhaps my thinking is a too-old fashioned, but isn’t it more important to make the opponent pay if they challenged you rather than simply preventing a pass from being completed?

                On the basis of this question, I’m going to say that DeAngelo Hall, considered overrated because he allows a lot of catches and is occasionally burned, is every bit as good a corner as Nnamdi Asomugha, considered one of the best corners in the NFL.

                ……………Don’t look at me in that tone of voice. Hear me out.

                I’m not saying that DeAngelo Hall is without his flaws. He gambles way too much and will more often than not try to strip the ball rather than tackle the receiver. He also doesn’t play up tight that often, giving a good deal of cushions and is content to simply allow catches in front of him rather than trying to prevent those catches. All of those are a given, but that being said, Asomugha is hardly a dangerous corner either. While there isn’t a large sample to look at, since teams rarely throw at him, he has only 11 career interceptions (8 coming in one season) and barely registers in terms of recovering or forcing fumbles. His entire career, fear and all, is built off of one great season he had in 2006.

                The point being is that both are great corners. Both are in the top ten or twelve of corners in the NFL, but neither is among the top three and neither is complete. The best corners are those guys that most consistently do both. Think about Deion Sanders. Deion was known for taking away half of the field and rarely ever being challenge by opposing quarterbacks. However the reason he was so feared is because whenever he got the ball in his hands, he was a threat to take it to the house, and he was very good at taking the ball away. In fact, you could almost say that Deion was the best combination of Asomugha and Hall. He had Asomugha’s ability to scare teams away and Hall’s playmaking ability. That is the kind of corner who should be considered the best.

Thursday, February 24, 2011

Top 5 Worst Arguments Against Induction in the Hall of Fame


The references to the Hall of Fame in this article are confined to the Pro Football Hall of Fame.

                The Top 5 Worst Arguments against Hall of Fame induction

                5. They didn’t play long enough/they were compilers.

                                While these may seem like two separate arguments, they are based on the same premise; that there is certain window in which a player must be dominant for them to be a Hall of Famer. In simpler terms, it’s used as an excuse in many cases to simply dismiss cases without actually examining them. For example, the argument most often used against Terrell Davis, who was the best runningback in the NFL when he played, is that he didn’t play long enough, while someone like Jerome Bettis or Curtis Martin will often be tagged with the compiler label because of their long careers, but were never considered “great.” I do agree that certain players can fall into these categories, like Priest Holmes or Keenan McCardell, however they’re used way too loosely and without any understanding of the context in which those players played. For example, Gale Sayers played a very short period of time, but was so dominant in the time he played that he made the Hall of Fame in spite of playing 7 years (and combining for less than 100 rushing yards and 0 touchdowns in the last two). Also, there’s Jerry Rice, who was long since surpassed for the title of best receiver in the league when he retired, could’ve have been considered a compiler since he continued searching for a job even when it was evident that he just didn’t have it anymore. Really the biggest issue I have with this is that it’s completely arbitrary as to how long constitute too short or too long. Some players who play 15 or 16 years are considered ironmen, while others are merely considered compilers. It’s a ridiculous and obvious excuse to exercise bias against certain players. 

Saturday, February 5, 2011

Super Bowl Preview

Well this is it. The Super Bowl is just about here. So, as is traditional and before I put myself in a calorie coma from too much red meat, let’s cover a preview of this game, position-by-position. We’ll start off with the grinders in the middle.

Offensive-Line: It’s odd that for a pair of teams that have come this far and have had so much success through the course of the regular season and post season would have such maligned offensive lines. This is especially true of the Steelers offensive line. All of that certainly has to do with the amount of injuries that the Steelers offensive line has suffered. Planned starting tackles Willie Colon and Max Starks have missed the majority of this season with injuries, leaving the responsibility of protecting Ben Roethlisberger’s flanks to Flozell Adams and Jonathan Scott. Scott has been pretty good in the running game and can stonewall weak pass rushers, but does struggle with faster players (like Clay Matthews).