Thursday, February 24, 2011

Top 5 Worst Arguments Against Induction in the Hall of Fame


The references to the Hall of Fame in this article are confined to the Pro Football Hall of Fame.

                The Top 5 Worst Arguments against Hall of Fame induction

                5. They didn’t play long enough/they were compilers.

                                While these may seem like two separate arguments, they are based on the same premise; that there is certain window in which a player must be dominant for them to be a Hall of Famer. In simpler terms, it’s used as an excuse in many cases to simply dismiss cases without actually examining them. For example, the argument most often used against Terrell Davis, who was the best runningback in the NFL when he played, is that he didn’t play long enough, while someone like Jerome Bettis or Curtis Martin will often be tagged with the compiler label because of their long careers, but were never considered “great.” I do agree that certain players can fall into these categories, like Priest Holmes or Keenan McCardell, however they’re used way too loosely and without any understanding of the context in which those players played. For example, Gale Sayers played a very short period of time, but was so dominant in the time he played that he made the Hall of Fame in spite of playing 7 years (and combining for less than 100 rushing yards and 0 touchdowns in the last two). Also, there’s Jerry Rice, who was long since surpassed for the title of best receiver in the league when he retired, could’ve have been considered a compiler since he continued searching for a job even when it was evident that he just didn’t have it anymore. Really the biggest issue I have with this is that it’s completely arbitrary as to how long constitute too short or too long. Some players who play 15 or 16 years are considered ironmen, while others are merely considered compilers. It’s a ridiculous and obvious excuse to exercise bias against certain players. 

Saturday, February 5, 2011

Super Bowl Preview

Well this is it. The Super Bowl is just about here. So, as is traditional and before I put myself in a calorie coma from too much red meat, let’s cover a preview of this game, position-by-position. We’ll start off with the grinders in the middle.

Offensive-Line: It’s odd that for a pair of teams that have come this far and have had so much success through the course of the regular season and post season would have such maligned offensive lines. This is especially true of the Steelers offensive line. All of that certainly has to do with the amount of injuries that the Steelers offensive line has suffered. Planned starting tackles Willie Colon and Max Starks have missed the majority of this season with injuries, leaving the responsibility of protecting Ben Roethlisberger’s flanks to Flozell Adams and Jonathan Scott. Scott has been pretty good in the running game and can stonewall weak pass rushers, but does struggle with faster players (like Clay Matthews).

Tuesday, February 1, 2011

Handicapping the Hall of Fame Election

                Well, next week the NFL season wraps itself in a blanket of media coverage and flashbulbs and settles in for hibernation until September (November if the potential lockout gets really bad). However, the day before we fans indulge in the warm glow of the Super Bowl and the warm embrace of Buffalo wings and beer, 44 sports writers will gather in North Texas to decide who will be enshrined in the Pro Football Hall of Fame.

                I’m not going to sit here and ask that you care about this, nor am I going to try and implore onto you the importance of the Hall of Fame. However, one of the most common debates amongst any sports fan is; who should be in the (respective) Hall of Fame?

Sunday, January 23, 2011

Championship Weekend Preview

                GB vs. CHI

                                 While they split the series over the course of the regular season, it’s difficult to say how good of an indicator those games were. In the first game, the Packers were still dealing with the loss of Ryan Grant to injury and in the second game the Bears really didn’t have anything to play for. Since the playoffs began, James Starks has given the Packers the kind of running game that they have lacked up to this point. He may not break off huge runs or have any kind of pack-breaking power, but he gets the tough yards when the Packers need them the most. His tough running, combined with a variety of run heavy packages the Packers utilize to pound opposing defenses, has provided enough balance to allow the passing game to flourish. However the Bears are strong in the middle of their defense and have a relatively deep secondary. The Bears have also done a very good job casing turnovers and forcing opposing quarterbacks into bad decisions. While they didn’t get any turnovers in their first game against Seattle (and the score would indicate that they allowed a relatively weak offense to dominate them,) they were able to make plays when they needed to, and only in the end of the game when they eased off the gas pedal did they allow the Seahawks back in it.

Saturday, January 15, 2011

Divisional Playoff Weekend Preview

                BAL vs. PIT

                                 Perhaps we should refer to this as the body-bag rivalry; there are enough injuries every time these two teams face off for it to qualify.  While the regular season saw these teams play two very tight games, it simply may not be the case this time. Both teams do know each other’s scheme’s fairly well, however the Ravens have struggled more through the season to have a dynamic, quick strike passing offense and, more importantly, to have a shutdown passing defense. While the Chiefs struggled to get their passing game going, it was more a case of the Chiefs not having receivers, other than Dwayne Bowe, who were capable of creating separation against the Ravens secondary.

Monday, January 10, 2011

BCS National Championship Game Preview

Oregon vs. Auburn  

                I’m not really sure what I can say about these hasn’t already been said, but to me this game basically boils down to this: Can the Auburn defense slow down the Oregon offense enough for Auburn to win the game? Oregon likes to run their offense at warp-speed, getting up to the line and snapping the ball as fast as possible, by doing this, they limit the number of substitutions their opponents can make. This allows young quarterback Darron Thomas to make simple reads and decisions about whether or not he keeps the ball in the zone read option. Thomas is a dangerous runner, but the big play threat that got Oregon here has been LaMichael James and Kenjon Barner. Both of whom have excellent speed and are difficult to tackle in the open field. The Auburn defensive backs and linebacker must be able to wrap up James and Barner when given the opportunity. Also, as odd as it sounds, the linebackers and defensive backs cannot simply maintain their gap assignments and wait for the ball to come to them, because of the speed of the Oregon runners. Instead they must attack the running lanes before the runners have a chance to get the edge. However this means that the defensive backs must also be strong in coverage, as Oregon likes to use misdirection and play-action to help open up the passing game. Man coverage will help limit communications breakdowns in the secondary, but the misdirection plays will be difficult for the Auburn corners not to bite on. Auburn does have one major advantage in the play of Nick Fairley, who is almost unblockable one-on-one. He should be able to slow down the rushing offense by penetrating along the interior and forcing runs to bounce further outside than they should. This will give the linebackers and defensive backs more time to determine who has the ball and pursue that ball carrier.